Skip to content

Want to create a new Google Ads account?

You're about to create a new Google Ads account. You can create multiple campaigns in the same account without creating a new account.

Want to create a new Google Ads account?

You're about to create a new Google Ads account. You can create multiple campaigns in the same account without creating a new account.

How to outsmart the 85% of ads failing the YouTube vibe check

A large inflatable red YouTube play button sits on a lawn in front of King's College Chapel, Cambridge. Three circular blue icons representing a lightbulb, drafting tools, and media players float in an arc above it.

It is both the best and worst of times to be a brand builder.

It’s never been faster or more affordable to create content: GenAI has triggered a 20-50% decrease in production and third party costs. Yet as a result, there’s been a massive influx of creative output and competition. Brands that previously counted themselves out of the online video race are now in a position to actively challenge established industry leaders.

Which is compounded by the fact that the sector has never had so much access to the theory of marketing — the likes of Mark Ritson and Les Binet have driven a veritable renaissance in rigour. This has elevated the standard across the board, but also made outthinking the competition an even greater challenge.

To rise to the occasion — and indeed the top — creative quality remains your biggest lever. 60%1 of overall YouTube sales contribution is down to creative, and if you optimise for the platform, you can double your ROI.

Levelling up from meh to masterpiece

Despite YouTube’s reach, 85%2 of advertising across Europe, the Middle East, and Africa doesn’t meet ABCD creative best practice guidelines. Which means that by taking steps to rectify this, and introducing more creative variety, you’ll immediately gain an advantage.

Fortuitously, the latter — i.e. improving creative variety — is simpler than you might think. The advent of YouTube’s AI-powered Video Reach (VRC) and Video View Campaigns (VVC), mean you can now upload a mix of aspect ratios and time lengths to show up as powerfully as possible across every YouTube-compatible surface and device.

Which matters because VRC campaigns that include at least three vertical videos are proven to be more effective at lifting brand awareness.3 You wouldn’t run a landscape out-of-home poster in a vertical bus stop placement. The same logic applies here.

Creative brilliance on YouTube comes from platform fluency — i.e. making creative that feels native to the environment. Here’s how:

  • Humour can improve your creative performance by 6.94 percentage points. This is especially true in the U.K. (no surprises there).
  • Casual language outperforms formal and over-scripted, which makes sense when you think about the nature of most YouTube content.
  • Shoot creator-style, using camera techniques such as extreme close-ups and quick cuts, to hold attention longer and drive an ROI uplift.

To further establish platform fluency, here are two easily deployable advertising tactics:

1. Play the long game

Unlike more traditional media, YouTube doesn’t restrict you to 30 or 60-second spot lengths. This means people move fluidly between short- and long-form content, and the most successful brands build campaigns to match that behaviour.

For long-form, our studies show that a 2 to 3 minute video duration delivers the highest consideration lift and cost efficiency.5

2. Tune for culture

The real magic happens when creative and media work together. Tools like Insights Finder allow brands to understand the audience’s specific interests, habits, and need states, which can then be built into creative variations.

Factors you can tailor include:

  • Mood and affinity: Build variants to reflect specific audience mindsets — gaming-inspired creative for gaming-interested audiences, for example.
  • Time of day and need state: A Friday night soundtrack and visual style is very different to what would work for a Wednesday mid-morning vibe.
  • Age and location: The creative possibilities here are vast. Auto brands have connected with students via lo-fi music for study periods, and furniture brands have tailored their outputs to night-owl sports fans watching highlights at 2 AM.

The proof is in the pudding

To make sure creative gets the credit it deserves, there’s a suite of advanced effectiveness tools brand builders can use to measure impact:

Make it happen

To develop true platform fluency and outperform competitors, advertisers should focus on three key areas:

Quality: Use YouTube’s ABCD principles to get ahead of 85% of the advertisers and cut-through on the channel.

Variety: Show up across the YouTube canvas by supplying both 16:9 landscape and 9:16 vertical assets, as a minimum.

YouTube brilliance: Build a truly platform-fluent campaign using techniques like shooting for the platform, playing the long game with extended durations, and tuning creative variants directly to audience culture.

By embracing these principles, you’ll be in a much stronger position to get ahead of the massive influx of content from your competitors, and use the unique, lean-in power of YouTube to turn attention into brand fame and fortune.

This article first appeared as part of YouTube Creative University. Watch all presentations here.

Ollie Latham

Creative Business Lead, U.K.

Google

Sources (4)

1 Based on an Ekimetrics Creative MMM meta analysis, 60% of overall YouTube sales contribution can be explained by only creative features.

Source: Ekimetrics creative MMM meta analysis including 4 U.S. brands and 9 EMEA brands commissioned by Google in 2024; Research spans 44 models and 2096 campaigns from Beauty, Luxury, Hospitality, and Automotive verticals between 2019 and 2024.

2 On average in Europe, 15% of the videos are qualified as “optimal” in terms of creative execution.

Source: 1) Ekimetrics creative MMM meta analysis including 9 European brands commissioned by Google in 2024; Research spans 24 models and 462 campaigns from Automotive, Beauty and Hospitality verticals between 2019 and 2024.

3 VRC campaigns that included at least three vertical videos were more effective at lifting brand awareness.: Google/YouTube Internal Data, (Global, Q2 2024 – Q1 2025).

4 On average, including humour in the video, holding all else constant, is associated with a 6.9% increase in ROI.

Source: Ekimetrics creative MMM meta analysis including 4 U.S. brands and 9 EMEA brands commissioned by Google in 2024; Research spans 44 models and 2096 campaigns from beauty, luxury, hospitality, and automobile verticals between 2019 and 2024.

Return to top of page