Ever wondered what a deep-dive into nearly 500 of Australia’s most effective marketing campaigns would reveal? To find out, we partnered with independent marketing consultant Robert Brittain, known for his seminal research on advertising effectiveness.
The Advertising Council Australia’s Australian Effie Awards are recognised as the pinnacle of advertising excellence. And the marketing campaigns contending for those accolades are a powerhouse of insights into what drives real ad effectiveness.
To uncover the secret to success amongst campaigns submitted between 2018 and 2025, Brittain isolated online video from Broadcast TV, Broadcast Video on Demand, Subscription Video on Demand, and social platforms.
Campaigns that include YouTube deliver 33% stronger overall business effects than those that don’t.
Source: ACA Effectiveness database, Australia, n=590 Effie Award Entrants from 2018-2025, analysed May 2026.
The conclusion from his extensive data analysis is clear: When it comes to maximising return on marketing spend, YouTube delivers.
In fact, campaigns that include YouTube deliver 33% stronger overall business effects than those that don’t.1 That holds true across hundreds of campaigns over seven years, and across categories and objectives at every campaign spend level.
That consistent performance comes down to how people watch. Winning the long game of brand building requires sustained active audience engagement, which thrives on YouTube as viewers intentionally choose to watch content they care about.
Unlike disengaged viewers who skip or scroll past ads, YouTube audiences accept advertising as part of the exchange for immersive experiences. They lean in, allowing messages to register and brand equity to build.
That’s why Meat and Livestock Australia (MLA) consistently chooses YouTube as its primary destination — and has six Effie Awards to show for it. Their iconic 2024 ‘Generation Gap’ Australian Lamb campaign drove record-breaking views, a 19% increase in purchase volume for that year, and propelled MLA’s core brand equity metrics to a near-decade high.
For MLA, YouTube acts as a powerful reach multiplier with a well-planned balance between paid views and organic amplification, fuelled by content like reaction videos that amplify total ad reach and drive repeat viewing. This is why MLA has strategically shifted 22% of their campaign budget to YouTube, a 4X increase from previous years.
While MLA’s multi-year success demonstrates how YouTube wins the long game, the platform is equally powerful at driving immediate, short-term impact.
Samsung’s Flipvertising marketing campaign proved exactly that. Using YouTube as its lead channel, the campaign drove 185,000 unique searches and 32% more pre-orders than the prior launch. This immediate success also generated long-term brand equity, by reframing Samsung as a brand that speaks the language of Gen Z.
Beyond immediate sales and long-term equity, the ultimate upside of YouTube is its direct impact on the bottom line. The Australian Effies Awards data reveals that brands incorporating YouTube into their media mix enjoy significantly higher profit growth than those that don’t. This performance multiplier spans the entire spectrum, from category leaders to smaller players.
Campaigns under $1 million that shift budget away from social and into YouTube see effectiveness increase by 30 to 65%, but YouTube increases campaign effectiveness at every level of spend.
Source: ACA Effectiveness database, Australia, n=590 Effie Award Entrants from 2018-2025, analysed May 2026.
Faced with wavering consumer confidence and heightened budget scrutiny, today’s marketers are under immense pressure to deliver certain returns. While they may be tempted to default to familiar, low-attention channels, Brittain’s data insights offer a clear alternative.
In his words: “Invest in YouTube where more people are engaged and attentive, because the return is there — and when it compounds, you’ll have more to reinvest, not less.”