Verified

Tomato Pie Pizza Joint (South Pasadena)

  • Pizza Restaurant in South Pasadena
  • Closed
  • 4.6
    (596)
Tomato Pie Pizza Joint (South Pasadena)
Reviews
4.6 out of 5
(596 reviews)
4.6
5
4
3
2
1
David Cho
7 months ago
Pro tip: parking is a little hard to find, but is there in back. Place is much larger than appears from the front. Took us a while to figure parking out. Wish there was a sign up front or something for new comers like us. Now for the pizza. I would describe their pizza as being good to very good. A few in LA a little better IMO so going with four stars. Crust was nice and crispy, NY style, but the primo lacked a bit of sauce for me. Preferred the Notorious SMG. GF got Mr white and I think the Florentine and agree the red sauced pizzas were a little better. Service was really nice and friendly and pretty quick considering they do reheat the slices for you after you order. Prices were reasonable as well. May have to try a whole pie and review again, but until then it’s A tier pizza but there are a few S tiers out there in LA so sticking with the four stars for now.
Suhas Yelluru
2 weeks ago
Really good pizza and garlic knots! This is a no-frills pizza spot that serves excellent NY-style pizza, whether you’re grabbing a slice or ordering a whole pie. They also have some great deals, like 2 slices and a drink for just $9.99, which is hard to beat. If you’re in the area and craving a good slice of pizza, this place is definitely worth checking out. Highly recommend, and I’ll absolutely be coming back.
Freddy
Edited 5 months ago
Just got back from eating here and all I can say are positive things. The location is beautiful and easy to find parking. The people that work there are incredibly nice and attentive. And the pizza was delicious!! Bonus for having my favorite beer on tap (Great White). I can’t wait to go back!
Miguel Soriano
Edited 6 months ago
all I can say is, YUM! The pizza we ordered tasted good, and I mean gooooood! The dining area will remind you of the 90's (correction, 60's... sorry I'm from the 90's) and the staff are very nice. I recommend this place to everyone reading this review.
David G
a month ago
We’ve been coming here for years. The food remains at it was. But the wait times have gotten ridiculous. The last two times — once was via Uber Eats delivery and the other a pickup order via DoorDash — resulted in 1.5 hour waits from the time of ordering to getting my food in hand. Both orders were very straightforward, not large or complex ones. During the most recent one, I was among about a dozen people waiting for our food, and there was no accountability from the front staff about anyone’s delayed orders. I don’t think the issue is staffing as they had plenty of workers. They just accept way more orders than they can efficiently handle through the apps. So while the food is good, I would say order here only if you (or your young kids) are okay with waiting…for a long while.
Carlo N.
2 years ago
Tomato Pie Pizza Joint is a pizza joint that makes the perfect NY-Style pizza in So.Pasadena. I arrived as a first time customer in this location. I was warmly greeted by a middle aged staff, at the counter. I perused their menu (pizza, pastas, subs, appetizers, salads) and decided to get a slice of Miss Green and Unsweetened Green Tea. Pizza was flavorful and its crust was great. It’s exactly the kind of NY style pizza taste that I’m accustomed growing up in NYC. Service was great. Staff were friendly. Atmosphere was relaxing. Their sleek interior 60’s design that stands out compared to other pizza joint. Prices seem fair. Plenty of street and rear parking lot. Overall, I loved every bite of Ms Green. I highly recommend this joint.
J C
2 years ago
Their pizzas are absolutely fantastic. A great balance between crunchy and soft. Not a lot of seating inside, I assume that’s why they don’t have fountain drinks in order to have a faster customer turn around. They offer by the slice as well. Very small parking lot in the back and a couple small tables outside. Limited canned and bottled drinks available. Their bathrooms are clean.
Rajat Gupta
2 years ago
Visiting family in South Pasadena from Canada, got here for a bite before a shopping trip .. Ordered a Caesar Salad, draft beer and a NY style Primo pizza which was cooked perfectly and had great flavour. Staff was very friendly and welcoming. Definitely coming back to try the other pizzas .
Maria Jupp
11 months ago
Brian had awesome customer service skills, very friendly and helpful. We tried 4 different slices pizzas and all are very tasty 🍕🥰 the house salad is all 💚 greens no iceberg lettuce here👏🎖🥗🍕🏆🥰 We'll be back to try another 4 different pizza slices. If you haven't eaten here come try a slice 😋 you won't be disappointed 😉
Gary Dunkel
4 years ago
As a New Yorker living in LA, I’m always on the hunt for good NYC style Pizza. This place is it! Tomato Pie Pizza Joint in South Pasadena is amazing! We got a Pepperoni, Mac n Cheese, and Syracuse Hot Wing slice! All we’re delicious and I can confirm that are definitely NYC status for pizza! The people that work there are very nice and I’ll definitely keep coming back! This place has me locked in!
Loading…
This site uses cookies from Google to deliver its services. By using this site, you agree to its use of cookies.