Nellie’s has a great atmosphere, especially with its waterfront setting, which really adds to the overall ambiance. We came for lunch and left somewhat satisfied, but also a bit disappointed. We ordered the crab cake sandwich and the blackened haddock sandwich, both with coconut onion rings.
The outdoor patio had quite a few birds around, but we didn’t mind, and the staff were actively trying to keep them away. The service itself was very good. Our server was attentive, friendly, and checked in on us regularly.
The prices were on the higher side, and there were no lunch specials, though that was expected given the area and waterfront location.
Unfortunately, the food was the biggest letdown. The coconut onion rings arrived lukewarm and hard, with the onion inside almost raw. The dipping sauce tasted like a bottled sweet and sour sauce rather than something freshly made. My blackened haddock was very overcooked, and the seasoning was inconsistent. Some parts were bland, while other bites were overly salty and heavily seasoned. The onion also was old and mushy. After the meal, my friend also felt extremely bloated and unwell.
Overall, Nellie’s delivers on atmosphere and service, but the food did not meet our expectations for lunch.