Charged for Their Own Mistake — Requesting a Fair Refund
UPDATE as of October 29th 2025
During our initial phone call, the shop owner, Steve, suggested he would issue a refund only if I took the review down. I made it clear that the refund would not be tied to removing the review, since my experience with the shop doesn’t change if they don’t take responsibility for their mistake. If they were willing to acknowledge the error and take proper responsibility, that would be the only reason I would consider updating the review.
Because they refuse to admit fault, this review will remain as-is. I want future customers to be careful this shop appears willing to charge for extra work that they themselves caused, rather than covering mistakes made during service. Since they have ignored my attempts to resolve the matter, I will be proceeding with small claims to recover the amount owed. (I will keep everyone updated on the outcome.)
I brought my 1996 Corolla here to have a stripped vehicle speed sensor (VSS) bolt removed. During the work, the shop dropped part of the sensor into the transmission and told me they would charge extra to remove it. I was subsequently billed $191.63 (about 32% of my total bill) for labor, parts, fluids, and proportional fees/taxes to fix their mistake.
At the time, I didn’t realize charging me for work caused by their mistake was prohibited, but I later confirmed that under Michigan’s Automotive Repair Act, a shop cannot bill a customer for labor or parts caused by poor workmanship. This portion of the bill is clearly the shop’s responsibility.
I value transparency and ethical business practices, and I hope the shop agrees to resolve this promptly. I am requesting a $191.63 refund for the work caused by their error and am open to resolving this privately for a fair outcome.