By no means great, or even very good...mediocre is probably the most fitting word for the pizza. My slice did have a decent undercarraige w/zero flop; not the same as the Mike & Joe's location on rt. 82 whatsoever, very nice people though.
Update: Went back with a colleague last week, asked for a pepperoni slice, counter guy said no pepperoni, but a pepperoni pie would be coming out in 10 minutes, so after my buddy ordered a cheese slice, I asked the guy to just put some pepperoni on a cheese slice...he wasn't having it. The pizza came out tof the oven quick and guess what, it was a disgusting, undercooked sloppy and floppy mess. I will never again go back to this pizzeria.